PDA

View Full Version : Neutrality and Trade.



Aleria Fadeleaf
10-12-2009, 03:45 PM
(Transcript of the spoken testimony of Ms. Aleria Fadeleaf, given to interested parties in the sectors of trade, martial interest, and emissaries of the crown earlier this morning, the twelfth day of the tenth month.)

Ms. Fadeleaf: Good Morning. I suppose I should be happy that I am not speaking to you today in front of a court, but I feel the need to explain last night's events in a greater detail than reports would have mentioned. As I am just learning this morning, the alarm bells were not sounded after the discovery of a thief, or a rogue assassin... I offer my deepest condolences to you, my friends and neighbors in the wake of this trajedy.

Last night the Wandering Tavern operated as usual, offering a venue for returning soldiers, and civillians trying to sort out what had happened. Toward the end of the night, two people, identified by the Stormwind Royal Cavalry as Sin'dorei, peacefully attended, drawing the ire of many local groups. That night, an accusation of treason was lodged against me for upholding my policies of neutrality. Thankfully, however, the charge was rebuked.

My policies of neutrality have puzzled a good number of my customers. Many of them come to me in desperation, telling me of all of the reasons why I should allow them to shoot that Blood Elf who had come in for a drink. Many of you are staring at me, wondering how I could ever stand by this... I intend to put this matter to rest today.

For those of you who are unfamiliar with my background, I once served as an ambassador, representing Lord Frederick Narrius. While "the Narrius delegation" was a controversial matter at the time, and still under contention, I advocated for peace, often to people who didn't want to hear what I had to say, and were not hesitant to let me, and the people who cared for me afterward, know that in no uncertain terms. Regardless of this experience, and everything that has been done, I still believe cooperation with the Horde is possible... although, I will say that the time has come for the Horde, not the Alliance, to come to the table, and prove that they will cooperate, instead of using one arm to fight the Lich King, and the other to sabotage our efforts to do the same. Put simply, I have strong personal reasons to run my business on a neutral basis. I believe that peace and cooperation are both possible, and that trade is one way to promote that goal.

Secondly, I operate on a neutral basis for the safety of my customers. A little over a year ago, the Golden Tree tavern closed its doors for the last time, something that saddened me greatly. I remembered the Golden Tree almost eight months ago when I started the Wandering Tavern, and among those memories, I remembered that it was a target.

The Golden Tree, operating in a stable location, at a certain time each week, became the unfortunate target of Horde attacks, and in many cases, House Blackstone did not hesitate to retaliate. Their policies were at first neutral, if memory serves, but eventually they changed thier minds, directly favoring the Grand Alliance over the Horde... and so came the attacks. In these attacks, many of his majesty's subjects were injured, and even killed. Economic growth was stunted, and the city had to be prepared for another assault on a tavern...

Pushing for one side or another would do the same to the Wandering Tavern, and establish us as a target, putting many innocent people in harm's way. I do not wish to take that risk, with my employees, with my customers, and with the community, whatever the surrounding community may be.

Finally. The Wandering Tavern advocates neutrality because it makes sense from a business perspective. I had been looking over my ledger, on my way over here, and I noticed that there existed a trend: when members of the Horde were present, I saw a dip in sales. This is of course to be expected, and unfortunately, such is unavoidable. I cannot control whether or not a member of the Horde decides to attend, but I also noticed another trend: profits, and overall revenues were considerably higher when the member of the Horde was not attacked by belligerent customers. I recall the worst week we had ever seen, south of here at the Westbrook Garrison, where the Wandering Tavern lost fifty to sixty gold peices, and if not for a quick restructing of accounts, would have been forced to shut down.

Many of you may be wondering, what do my profits have to do with the Kingdom of Stormwind, 'How do they help me?' Well, consider this. Every copper peice I bring in is used to do one of three things: pay suppliers, pay employees, or to expand. Those payments in turn go to other businesses within the Alliance, who do the same, and create a cycle, a flow of money, just like the necessary flow of blood in a living being. In the midst of that flow, the crown takes taxes, taxes used to create orphanages and schools for our children, taxes for infrastructure, taxes to finance two wars, against the Burning Legion, and the Lich King. Money that saves lives on the battlefield, by giving our soldiers what they need to defeat Arthas. The success of business in this kingdom, therefore, is inexorably tied to the success of the Alliance.

But then the question still arises, 'why would you trade with the Horde?' Aside from the reasons I have given, there is one more, one that we should all consider:

We need them.

-Ms. Fadeleaf pauses as worried whispers fill the room.-

Ms. Fadeleaf: I ask you today to look at the state of our farmlands, and of our once proud mining industry. What state is it in? Petty thieves, to this day have overtaken the once breadbasket of the Alliance, Westfall. We have two or three farms that I can think of today that are operating at a modest capacity. The McClure Farm, The Stonefield farm, and a small orchard just outside of the city gates. The rest however, are inoperable, crippled by a gang of thieves who have yet to be properly confronted.

The need for food may not be so well outlined at the moment, but consider that many of our outposts, instead of being supplied by our now embattled farmers, must scavenge for food in the local area. The problem is most acute in outposts on Draenor, where soldiers endure stomach problems caused by 'Outland food.'

We are operating at our current capacity, and it still isn't enough. It seems that the Alliance has an easier time wrenching food from the Forsaken, who have invaded Strom, than we can from our own farmlands! In our desperation, many of our merchants have turned to the Steamwheedle Cartel, the Kirin Tor, and different groups in the outland.

The Horde by contrast, is an emerging society, whose nations often have small capital accounts, a situation which trends toward agrarian economies. In addition, they are, for the most part, resource deprived, with depleted mines in Lordaeron, and sparse mineral reserves, and a percieved need to invade another country to satisfy lumber needs. They trade with these groups as well.

In other words, we trade coin, minerals, and sometimes lumber to the Steamwheedle Cartel, and other groups in exchange for coin, food, and various commodities, while the Horde trades with them for resources that they cannot procure on their own, for food that they can provide in exchange.

By now, it should be apparent, we have supplied the Horde with many of the resources they now use to bolster their militaries, and in return, they're feeding us. Even if both sides are not aware of this, they are inexorably tied to one another.

Whether this is good or bad is up to you to decide, but if we are to end this cycle, we must regain our lands, in a time where we are fighting two wars, and at a time where we are marching toward a third. Tactics and military strategy are all well and good, but logistics must also be thoroughly considered by both sides.

In the meantime however, trade is strenghthening both, and while many will disagree with me, I believe in neutrality in trade and business because in the end, we need each other for our respective wants and needs.

Villayna
10-12-2009, 05:19 PM
(( hehe, love it ))

Keldorin
10-13-2009, 12:26 PM
(( Will you please join The Pale or Ashen Heart? xD ))

Sejarki
10-13-2009, 12:40 PM
(( So if the Alliance conquers the Horde its people get their food, right? ))

Okhu
10-13-2009, 12:44 PM
(( Not if I lick it all first. Orc germs don't wash off you know. You gotta burn the entire crop. Otherwise anyone that eats it will turn green and tusky and start spouting stuff in Orcish....next thing you know they burned their old house and moved in with the Horde! ))

Rohan Orcslayer
10-13-2009, 12:55 PM
(( So if the Alliance conquers the Horde its people get their food, right? ))

((/target Sejarki
/smack))



(( Not if I lick it all first. Orc germs don't wash off you know. You gotta burn the entire crop. Otherwise anyone that eats it will turn green and tusky and start spouting stuff in Orcish....next thing you know they burned their old house and moved in with the Horde! ))

((Stop licking the pigs!))

Aleria Fadeleaf
10-13-2009, 09:59 PM
(( Will you please join The Pale or Ashen Heart? xD ))

((Ms. Fadeleaf's connections to House Re-Tasj run far too deep for that. Sorry. :( ))

(Continued Transcript. Question and Answer session.)

Ms. Fadeleaf: Yes, you there in the back.

-Question is asked by Mr. Arthur Gerard, who represents the Eastvale Linens Company.-

Mr. Gerard: Thank you for your time, I'd like to address that last part regarding the invisible trade you mentioned with the Horde... you mentioned that they currently have an agrarian economy, could you explain that please?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Certainly. Economies like ours have had a long time to establish, and have long passed the age where food was our only concern. Toward the beginning of a civilization, the most immediate needs are the ones which are met first: food, basic shelter, a sustainable source of drinking water, all important things necessary to survival. This is something true of any culture, regardless of the surrounding natural resources. There may be some urgency for the creation of weapons, but basic needs must be met, or there is no nation.

The Horde, for the most part, is an emerging society. Nations like Durotar and Thunder Bluff have only been recently established, and they have yet to create the same infrastructure nations such as Ironforge pridefully employ. Nations like Ironforge have an advantage in producing manufactured goods over nations such as Durotar and Thunder Bluff, because those nations are still developing. This is also a situation which is true of Darnassus and the Azuremyst Isles, I may add, but farming is not as widespread there. Instead, they rely on the large fishing industries of Auberdine, and more recently, Teldrassil.

But I'm getting off topic. Orgrimmar especially, and sometimes Thunder Bluff has a modest farming industry. It is still growing true, and is far behind the full capacity of Stormwind... if the fields were not infested with thieves, but there is a modest farming industry. What the Orcs do not consume themselves is quickly bought up by opportunistic Goblins, who in turn sell to us.

Mr. Gerard: Yes, but you're forgetting about the Forsaken and the Sin'dorei. Both cultures have been established for a very long time.

Ms. Fadeleaf: Actually, I'm glad that you brought that up, because I was about to get to them. Ordinarily, yes, Lordaeron and Quel'thalas should have large, established capital accounts, and while I would argue, they are larger than that of their allies, these are both ravaged countries, which to this day are picking of the pieces of the Third War. The Forsaken I'm afraid, do not have much of an economy, because most of their resources were used during the Third War. This may be one of the reasons why they embarked on the invasion of Strom.

Mr. Gerard: Do you see any future for the Forsaken at all?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Hmm... manufacturing, if they could import the materials... global banking and the provision of finance is another option."

Mr. Gerard: And what about Quel'thalas?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Quel'thalas has to deal with a similar situation. It never had sound resources to begin with. No established ore deposits, and a vibrant forest which they don't want to touch, for the same reasons the Kal'dorei have for not seeking to benefit from their forests. Their lands too were also ravaged during the third war, and approximately half of their lands were blighted by Arthas' invasion. However, fishing is still an industry there to consider, as well as the production of fruit.

Mr. Gerard: This brings me to my last question... you mention all of this, and you mention that in exchange we are supplying them. What if we were just to edge in on those industries ourselves?

Ms. Fadeleaf: In what way?

Mr. Gerard: Well, what if we took these lands for the Alliance? ((It takes me this long to respond to Sejarki... I need to find a better way to do this.))

Ms. Fadeleaf: It wouldn't make much of a difference. I mentioned earlier that the Orcish farming industry is not nearly what ours would be if not for our loss of control of them. If you want to regain our edge in agriculture, it would be best to look for solutions closer to home. Not to mention, we do not have the available resources to go to war with the Horde... we don't even seem to have the resources to dive those thieves from our fields, or to drive the Blackrock clan from Lakeshire. The Horde is having the same problem, and this is because we are still fighting two wars at once, against the Lich King, and the Burning Legion.

Finally, even if you were to take the lands, you wouldn't get much from them at first, due to resistance and sabotage. You'll notice that despite the enormous logging operations in Ashenvale, there is very little new construction in Durotar, and this is because the Warsong Clan has to use the lumber to repair damaged facilities, and loses product due to that sabotage and their own inefficiencies. In fact, with their current need for more soldiers to stave off the Silverwing Sentinels, it is becoming an operation which, if everything was expressed on a Balance Sheet in values of gold pieces, would show consistent negative changes to their gold reserves.

Mr. Gerard: Yes, but wouldn't we be able to fight them more effectively if we defeated the Horde first? They have been sabotaging our efforts to fight the Lich King.

Ms Fadeleaf: There is a school of thought which believes that, yes, and I admit there were times when I would consider it. But we mustn't forget two things. First, we would need a quick, and decisive victory in order for it to be effectual. Every second where we have to pull resources away from other battles is time that the Lich King can use to reverse the tide in Northrend. You would essentially have to raze Orgrimmar in a month, something that I believe is outright impossible. Secondly, we would benefit far more from simple cooperation. It would have the effect of doubling our current presence there, really, and the trade would allow for specialization, and an overall increase in our combined production capacity.

Aleria Fadeleaf
11-17-2009, 12:15 AM
(Transcript: Third Week of the Eleventh Month)

Ms. Fadeleaf: I would like to keep things brief this morning, as I have quite a bit to attend to. Who would like the honor of asking the first question?

-Maria Hammond, representing the People's Militia of Westfall, rises to ask the first question.

Ms. Hammond: First off, thank you for your time, I will try to keep my question short. In a weekly report given back from the Westfall Brigade in Northrend, you hosted your tavern at the Redwood Trading Post, and that several members of the Horde, including at least one documented member of the Raven Cross were in attendance, is that correct?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Yes, that is correct.

Mrs. Hammond: And, as I understand the report, you did nothing? You didn't send them away?

Ms. Fadeleaf: That is also correct.

Mrs. Hammond: Finally, I understand that they, in the end, harmed numerous taverngoers of the Alliance.

Ms. Fadeleaf: Yes... regrettably that is also correct.

Mrs. Hammond: So then, given your conduct, how do you respond to an accusation of treason?

Ms. Fadeleaf: I would first like to point out that war has not yet erupted. It seems that everyone has grown so complacent, and so itchy for war, that they so easily forget what it really looks like. This is not a war, this is the state of affairs right before a war, and I continually state that while we tread upon dangerous soil, we have not yet reached the point of no return. Therefore, seeing that the process of negociations have not been explicitly halted, and that the Horde and the Alliance still collaborate, even as thinly as they do, that the charge of treason is brought out at the wrong time.

Mrs. Hammond: So then what would you call letting the Horde attack our people who came to your tavern?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Well, it's a nuanced issue.

Mrs. Hammond: What do you mean by that?

Ms. Fadeleaf: At the very beginning, there were two members the Horde present, and orc and a blood elf. Things were relatively calm for a good long while. Sales were moving along as usual, and there were no problems aside from one spat which was quickly resolved. Another Sin'dorei arrived, the one which your records claim holds affiliation with the cross, but still no problems existed. Things were relatively calm until several customers went behind the tower, and started holding duels.

Mrs. Hammond: And then what?

Ms. Fadeleaf: The duels were not in the seating area, which omits my judgement, so I said not a word about it. It was when they spilled over into the seating area that I tried in vain to stop what was at that point, a tavern which was spiraling out of control. You might see the same kind of behaviour between people of two different towns in a disagreement, but due to my inability to resolve the conflict, it escalated.

Mrs. Hammond: Because of the Horde. Your policies allowed them to do what they did.

Ms. Fadeleaf: No, you are missing the point.

Mrs. Hammond: How am I missing the point? I have the report right here!

Ms. Fadeleaf: The report omits certain details.

Mrs. Hammond: Such as?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Such as the fact that members of the Alliance were by and large, responsible for the escalation, and refused to acknowledge me as I tried to stop them.

Mrs. Hammond: Ms. Fadeleaf, I hold the report in my hands, do you pretend to dispute...

Ms. Fadeleaf: I do. That report is an after-the-fact analysis which was taken from the spoken testimony of human members of the Screwspigot shipping company. I've seen the report myself, and I have found missing details, and inaccurate recounts of the facts.

Mrs. Hammond: Even still, permitting the Horde's presence was dangerous. Had you dispatched of them earlier, this would have never happened.

Ms. Fadeleaf: I have numerous studies taken from revenue figures, and from incident reports which prove otherwise. Generally, the data suggests that when there is conflict between members of the Alliance and the Horde, that sales take a precipitous fall, and many of his majesty's subjects are injured in the process. In contrast, such effects are not anywhere near as prevalent if members of the Horde attend in peace. Attacking them directly would produce a conflict, which would do three things. First, it would damage already strained relations, second, it would reduce the amount of tax revenue being delivered to the Kingdom of Stormwind, and third, it would bring more harm to his majesty's soldiers.

Mrs. Hammond: Such risks must be taken. You of all people would not consider permitting the presence of those who time and again, ignore our sovereignty and defile our sacred values?

Ms. Fadeleaf: Not every orc is a proud member of the Warsong Clan. There are many, like me, who are seeking solutions to the problem, on both sides of this conflict, and in general, those are the sort of people from the Horde attracted to such functions. Those who wish to stir up trouble, will be there to stir up trouble, and those are the ones who I will not lift a finger to protect. As for myself though, I am a tavernkeeper, I don't run a military outpost, and I won't pretend to.

Mrs. Hammond: You say this, and yet you have spoken favorably of ideas to finance members of the Horde wishing to start their own taverns under your umbrella. You would finance their ability to make war in that sense. You are not proposing to give money to moderates.

Ms. Fadeleaf: No, I'm afraid I would have to meet with them to confirm that they would be feasable... and I seriously doubt that, say a disgruntled tauren who believes that Night Elves are nothing but scum would agree to have one as a superior. I just don't see that as being possible.

Mrs. Hammond: And yet you would indirectly support that Tauren.

Ms. Fadeleaf: I've been over this before. Trade binds, and we're already indirectly supporting people who we generally don't get along with well. I argue that instead of that being discouraged however, that it should be encouraged.

Mrs. Hammond: They are the Horde, they are diametrically opposed to us, I think your grip on reality is rather weak, Ms. Fadeleaf.

Ms. Fadeleaf: I can easily say the same thing for you, but it will hardly get us anywhere. I have mentioned my reasons for believing what I believe, the Horde and the Alliance indirectly trade with one another, and support each other in such a fashion, which, in my mind, highlights the difference between positions and interest. The Horde and the Allaince for the most part want the same thing: a world in which our families can live Yet we have allowed the position we take, to deny anything but the ascription of the Alliance or the Horde.

I understand that there are problems, and I have been quick to highlight instances where the Horde have refused to acknowledge their own abuses, and places where they are in need of improvement, but I do not believe that out of an incalcuable set of outcomes, that only one can be considered as "possible." I don't ascribe to the belief of pure concession, but I also don't ascribe to the idea that a war is inevitable and necessary. I believe in coexistance, a fundamental understanding of the positions we take, and most importantly, why we take them.

Lurile
11-17-2009, 04:52 PM
Interesting, I do admit her neutrality policy is worth sustaining...*mills over the paper some more* I wonder if I have any children....

*Finishes the article, tossing his gazette to the side*

But we do NOT need the Horde.